Gainesville's Best Italian Family Restaurant & Pizzeria

Authentic Italian Cuisine in Gainesville, VA

Family Owned and Operated Italian Pizzeria & Restaurant

Est. 2008


Dine from your home

Want to enjoy our delicious pizza or speciality Italian entrees at home? We offer carry out and delivery. Call in or order online!

5 mile radius and $3 delivery fee apply.

Outside our delivery radius? Be sure to use one of our delivery partners


Beer, Wine, Brunch, and Specials!

We have a large selection of imported and domestic draft beers and Italian wines to fit your taste. We make sure to provide a reasonably priced fine wines to make your dine in experience great. 

Be sure to ask about our Lunch & Dinner Specials and Weekend Brunch menu to enjoy some of our unbeatable Food & Drink deals.


Hosting a party and need food? WE CATER!

Each of our dishes is inspired directly from Italian recipes. Share your favorite dish with all your family, friends, or coworkers! Call or email us directly for any catering inquiries. 

Prefer to speak to Giuseppe directly to arrange catering?

Call 703.753.0744 or email



Gelato & Family Fun!

Our gelato is awarding winning and provided directly by one of the best gelato makers in the USA. Kids love our wide selection of gelato and other specialty Italian desserts. As a family restaurant its our pleasure to see each member of your family smiling! 

Our Story

About Us

Pizza NY Margherita is a family owned and operated restaurant. The restaurant was founded by the D’Agostino family. The family moved together from Naples, Italy and started Tony’s NY Pizza in 1994. In 2008, Pizza NY Margherita was founded and we are proud to be serving the best pizza in Gainesville. Now you can find Giuseppe present at the restaurant greeting each customer. Please stop by and say hello, we love meeting each of our customers!

We love partnering with local sports teams, schools, religious groups, and offer Military and teacher discounts with valid ID present!